muihuong.vnScent keeps what you forget. Tiếng Việt

Research · Volume 4. Odour molecules and human olfactory anatomy · 5/7

Part V. Synthesis

Reference values, numerical conflicts traced to their sources, genuine gaps in the field and implications for fragrance product design.

5.1 Table of reference values

The table below collects the foundational numbers of human olfaction, together with an assessment of reliability. This is the table to use when a number needs to be cited in internal documents or website content.

Table 7. Reference values for human olfaction
QuantityValue to useReliabilityNotes
Proportion of inhaled airflow reaching the olfactory cleft~1–15%, lower in older adultsLow–moderateAll from simulations; do not use “10%” as a constant
Optimal sniff parameters~30 L/min, ~200 cm³, ~0.4 secondsModerateOne study, n = 21
Nasal cycle~2 hours awake, ~4.5 hours asleepFair33/33 people had a cycle
Olfactory epithelium areaNo modern valueVery lowOnly measurement: 2 cadavers in 1892
Total number of sensory neuronsNo counted valueVery low“6–20 million” is an estimate
Intact receptor genes~350–400FairPer Volume 3
Glomeruli per bulb~5,000–8,000FairNot 1,100–1,200
Glomeruli per receptor gene~16 (human) versus ~2.5 (mouse)ModerateHuman count on 7 bulbs
Mitral cells per bulb (young people)~40,000–51,000ModerateFall sharply with age
Olfactory bulb volumeCompare only within the same protocolModerate2.5-fold difference between laboratories
Olfactory bulb neuron turnover< 1% after 100 yearsFairOne carbon-14 study; a rapidly renewing subpopulation is not excluded
Piriform volumeCompare only within the same definitionModerate~66–510 mm³ depending on definition
Enantiomer pairs discriminated3/10 at group levelModerateOne study, n = 20
Odour-threshold variance explained by physicochemistry~76%Fair353 compounds

5.2 Data conflicts traced to their source

Table 8. Data conflicts and how they were handled
TopicValuesCause / conclusion
Number of glomeruli1,100–1,200 / 5,568 / ~8,000Resolved: the first figure has no count in humans; the latter two are compatible once specimen age is taken into account
Proportion of olfactory airflow~10%, <10%, <15%, 1.2–7.7%, 3–15%, 11.1 ± 7.4%Differences in regional definition, nasal geometry, age, simulated flow rate
Retronasal routeModel: more sensitive / Measurement: less sensitiveUnresolved; the model is based on only one person
Olfactory bulb volume67–71 mm³/bulb; 54 mm³ both bulbs; 50 mm³/bulbDifferent MRI and segmentation protocols
Piriform volume~66–188 / 228–252 / 461–510 mm³Different regional definitions
Piriform lateralityRight larger by 17.7% / 5% / left larger / histology: uncorrected rightward lateralisation in one areaUnresolved
Location of the olfactory epitheliumIncludes middle turbinate / superior turbinate onlyUnresolved; possibly due to specimens, differing criteria and individual variation
Mitral cells in young people~40,000 / ~51,000Counting method and sample (one all-female study)
Deuterated muskHumans discriminate ~90% / receptors do not discriminateUnresolved, but the behavioural result stands alone
α-synuclein in normal older adults7% / 20%Possibly mainly due to the definition of the control group
Mediodorsal thalamic lesionsDiscrimination normal / impairedUnresolved; only about 10 cases in total

5.3 The field’s genuine gaps

The gaps below are not due to limits on access to the literature; they are measurements that nobody has made:

  1. Olfactory epithelium area, and the total number and density of sensory neurons in humans — by modern methods and by age.
  2. The lifespan of olfactory sensory neurons in humans.
  3. The thickness and renewal rate of human olfactory cleft mucus.
  4. Kinetic constants of human olfactory enzymes with odorants, and the extent of metabolism within a single sniff.
  5. The functional role of odorant-binding proteins in humans.
  6. The atomic structure of a human odorant receptor in its native form.
  7. Quantitative transduction biophysics in human olfactory neurons.
  8. Combinatorial code size at physiological odour concentrations.
  9. Three-dimensional glomerulus counts on a large sample spread evenly across ages.
  10. The number of axons in the olfactory tract; the volume and neuron count of the anterior olfactory nucleus.
  11. Neuron counts and a transcriptomic atlas for the human piriform.
  12. The cytoarchitectonic borders of the olfactory area of the orbitofrontal cortex.
  13. Evaporation rates of aroma compounds from wood, wax and paper.

5.4 Implications for fragrance design and products

The implications below are the editorial team’s inferences from the data in this monograph.

  1. What customers smell may already have been transformed by their own noses. In vitro, many aromatic esters and aldehydes are substantially metabolised by mucus enzymes, whereas tertiary esters are almost untouched; in the breath, metabolites appear within a few seconds. When a note “smells different on each person”, part of the cause may lie in the chemistry inside the smeller’s nose rather than in the formula. For formulas that need to be stable across users, tertiary esters such as linalyl acetate are a less variable choice.
  2. Older customers smell with a different “nose”. According to simulations, airflow to the olfactory cleft falls from about 13–15% in children to about 3–5% in older adults; mucus volume falls by about 60%; the number of glomeruli falls by about 10% per decade. Products aimed at older people may need higher intensity — but this should be tested on that very group rather than inferred from a young panel.
  3. Sniffing instructions. According to one model, the main resistance lies in the mucosal phase, so for the same volume a longer sniff may be more effective than a stronger one — a hypothesis not yet tested in humans. The optimal parameters measured in humans are about 0.4 seconds at about 30 L/min.
  4. Two nostrils. The nasal cycle makes the two nostrils differ in flow at any given moment, and one experiment suggests that this alters the perception of mixtures. For serious sensory evaluation, smell with both nostrils, and repeat at a different time.
  5. Passive diffusion products need to be measured in-house. The collection strands found no peer-reviewed data on evaporation rates from wood or wax. For essential-oil-infused wood products, the release curve over days can only be known by weighing mass loss over time, or by measuring with headspace analysis equipment — and this is also valuable proprietary data.
  6. Do not assume that “chirality” makes a difference. Of the 10 enantiomer pairs tested, only 3 were discriminated at group level, although some individuals could discriminate as many as 6 pairs. Before paying a premium for a pure enantiomer, test each material separately on your own panel.
  7. Be cautious with poorly purified synthetic materials. In one large study, only 12/50 chemical samples had an odour genuinely caused by the nominal compound itself. For materials used at high concentration, impurities may determine the odour.

5.5 Correction to Volume 2

Section 3.3 of Volume 2 originally used the figure of 1,100–1,200 glomeruli per bulb in humans. This monograph establishes that the figure is not based on any count in humans; Volume 2 has been corrected to about 5,000–8,000, with the reason recorded in the errata log.

A monograph compiled from 259 sourced facts collected under a common protocol. Practical-implication sections are the compilers’ inferences. Diagrams are newly drawn from published data. Scientific reference material, not medical advice.